Sometimes something in the pop culture Zeitgeist seems to have its own gravitational pull. Something that you feel compelled to see, listen to, or experience. Something you wouldn’t necessarily describe as exciting, and yet it somehow ends up becoming one of your top priorities.
You Can See Everything is this type of … something.
See, I know this sounds obtuse, but the project itself defies categorization. It is a movie, and it is non-fiction, but it’s not quite a documentary. For the two of you reading this who haven’t heard anything about You Can See Everything, it’s about disgraced Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes and the days she spends with her family before beginning her prison sentence, which she decided to also spend alongside Nathan Fielder. I could take this a step further and note that Fielder himself is someone who defies categorization, but I have to make some kind of an attempt to rein this in.
I’m usually a little squeamish about films with longer runtimes (I think they’re lazy), so when I saw that You Can See Everything clocked in at nearly three hours, I balked. And yet when the lights came up afterward, I was ready to see it again. Part of that is because at the 90-minute mark, Holmes goes to prison, which one might think would be the end of the story. But that’s where Fielder and his collaborator, co-director Lance Oppenheim, deftly started telling another, bigger story. Mild spoilers in the next paragraph …
We get a potential villain (Holmes’s paramour Billy Evans), a mystery (armed with power of attorney, is Billy exploiting the imprisoned Holmes?), and a surprising revelation (has Fielder himself become entranced by Holmes, or has he simply fallen for her?).
At this point you might be thinking, “Dude, I’m here for the story strategies.” To that, I’d respond with a question: why do the stories that captivate our collective consciousness do so? Especially true stories that’ve been covered extensively in the news, podcasts, actual documentaries, and even a scripted Hulu series starring Amanda Seyfried, who shows up here and deserves the Oscar she will likely be nominated for.
So what story strategies make You Can See Everything hit? Turns out it employs some story strategies we’ve been talking about here:
Subvert Expectations
We all know how the Elizabeth Holmes story ends: prison. This film hands us that at the 90-minute mark, then keeps going for another 90 minutes. That turn traces back to Judee Burgoon’s expectancy violations theory. When something breaks our default pattern, our attention snaps to it as we scramble to make sense of what just happened. Suddenly, a story we thought we knew has a villain, a mystery, and a twist. Long story short? You want your audience to say, “I didn’t see that coming.” More on this Story Strategy.
Narrative Transportation
Stories take us places. As you’ve no doubt seen in memes and parodies, You Can See Everything uses close-ups. But they are extreme close-ups of a couple of people at a time. For three hours! The result of being this close to people for that long is that you start to put yourself into their circumstances. That’s narrative transportation in action. I’m not saying we all have an Elizabeth Holmes hiding under the surface, but you do start to imagine and feel what it would be like going to prison if you’d just welcomed a newborn. More on this Story Strategy.
The Stories We Tell Ourselves Are Powerful …
I say this a lot. In fact, I wrote about this last month with me and my marathon. Stories can help us to achieve great things, while negative self-talk can be paralyzing. My new story helped me believe I could run a marathon and overcome a negative story I had in my head. Problem: In watching this, it seems Elizabeth Holmes consistently believes a story in her head about her company and product and what they could do that simply isn’t true. And she seems to still believe it. Which is a problem because …
Changing Deeply Entrenched Stories Is Hard
It is possible to change a story, but it’s very hard. There’s a deliberate process, which I outlined last year. If this film was a shrewd PR move to change the public perception of Holmes, it’s fallen short. Guilty of defrauding investors, she has a huge trust gap in the public eye. While complicated, the movie depicts someone who’s at best very confused and at worst very manipulative. More on this Story Strategy.
The Ultimate Rorschach Test
Coming out of You Can See Everything, I said to the friendly faces at the box office, “I’m not sure what I just saw.” I’m not alone in this sentiment. The movie is something of a Rorschach Test. While that leaves us with opaque, inky perceptions, it’s perhaps the most potent ingredient in this story. If your audience is asking, “What was that?” it means they’re thinking about it.
Story Strategy: Name the Hook
Every story that captivates you is running a playbook, whether or not its makers know it.
Apply it: The next time a movie, a scandal, or a product launch won’t let go of you, stop and ask: which strategies are at work? A surprise turn? Extreme closeness to the characters? A story someone refuses to rewrite? Naming why it hooks you is how you borrow it for your own stories.
A version of this first appeared in Story Strategies—my monthly email newsletter designed to help you connect with your audience through the power of story. Get the next issue delivered to your inbox.
